RentYield Atlas

ZIP 12701 — Monticello, NY: rental yield & market data

Gross rental yield of 6.71% — ranked #110 of 418 New York ZIP codes. June 2026 data.

Gross rental yield
6.71%
Home value
$289,265
Market rent / mo
$1,617
Price-to-rent
14.9

Trend

Metric1-year change5-year change
Home value+3.3% +67.2%
Market rent

Metro: — · County: Sullivan County · Annual rent: $19,404

Comparable ZIP codes in New York

Similar home values, sorted by yield — the cheapest way to see if 12701 is actually the better buy.

ZIPCitySTHome valueRent/moYieldP/RValue 1y
14620RochesterNY$287,800$1,7387.25%13.8+1.6%
14626RochesterNY$294,471$1,6966.91%14.5+5.7%
14214BuffaloNY$297,350$1,5786.37%15.7+4.2%
14420BrockportNY$286,568$1,3445.63%17.8+4.7%
13224SyracuseNY$286,243$1,3055.47%18.3+4.1%
12305SchenectadyNY$287,177$1,2535.24%19.1-0.8%
14612RochesterNY$294,549$1,2685.16%19.4+4.5%
14120North TonawandaNY$290,991$1,1724.84%20.7+5.4%

Top rental yields in all of New York →

Full dataset — all 8,427 ZIP codes · $19 one-time

Screening more than one ZIP? Get every New York ZIP and all 49 other states at once. CSV, opens in Excel / Sheets / pandas. 13 columns incl. metro, county, price-to-rent, 1y & 5y value and rent growth.

Get the CSV — $19

Instant download after checkout · what's inside